SCEC logo SCEC INSTANeT News
Researchers Jolt a Fully Furnished Woodframe House ­ First Such Test Conducted in the United States

By Jill Andrews

On Tuesday, July 11, viewers were able to witness what happens to a house when it is hit with near-fault shaking recorded by a strong motion seismograph in the 1994 Northridge Earthquake in Los Angeles. Based on current design and building practices in California, the house had a tile roof, stucco exterior finish and all rooms were finished with painted gypsum board walls. This was the first time that the house had been fully furnished, with cameras installed to record the effect of strong motion on the building's equipment and contents, such as water heaters, shelving, TVs, bookcases, refrigerators and cabinets. The July 11 test was the culmination of five months of testing on the house, which had undergone a series of modifications to its configuration and materials and was subjected to a variety of different recorded earthquake motions played back through an earthquake simulator (or "shake table.")

The Woodframe Project, of which the UCSD testing was a part, is funded by the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) through a grant administered by the California Governor's Office of Emergency Services (OES). For more information on CUREe and this project, see www.curee.org. Information from this dynamic testing, as well as subsequent testing on the same house, will also be used to develop new standardized guidelines for adjusting insurance claims after an earthquake. The California Earthquake Authority (CEA) is funding this portion of the project.

Researchers at the Department of Structural Engineering at UCSD had been constructing, testing, and re-constructing the house in phases since early this year. The full-scale model was installed on the uniaxial shake table inside of one of UCSD's Department of Structural Engineering Powell Research Laboratories. The ground motion record for the July 11 test was the Rinaldi station recording of severe shaking in the Northridge Earthquake, with peak acceleration scaled slightly upward to 1.0g.

Information from 300 sensors installed inside and outside the house provided valuable data that researchers will use to create computer simulations expected to aid in evaluating current design and construction practices. One of the surprise outcomes appears to be the power of stucco: an earlier test on the bare wood structure revealed that the top of the house swayed back and forth five inches relative to the bottom. In the test on the stuccoed version, the top swayed only one inch. "Those materials have the potential of providing a lot of earthquake resistance," said Caltech's Prof. John Hall in an interview with the NY Times. "The building was quite a bit stronger than when we previously tested it."

Results from this and other tests to be done on other woodframe structures will be used to modify designs for new houses and for retrofit of existing buildings. For example, the California Earthquake Authority (CEA) Governing Board has recently approved a $300,000 research project on the house to develop the nation's first standardized claims adjusting guidelines for earthquake damage to woodframe homes. "This cutting-edge research is a giant step forward in helping us better serve our policyholders after an earthquake. For the first time, we will have a scientific and engineering basis for claims adjusting rather than using conjecture and guesswork," said Mark Leonard, spokesman for CEA.

Shake Test in the News:

More than 350 news stories were generated the day of the event and immediately following by print, radio and television reporters. Major television network news organizations covered the event: CNN, Fox News, CBS, NBC, ABC World News, Good Morning America and their affiliates. The Discovery Channel is preparing a story and website scheduled to appear soon. KNBC and KFWB Radio aired stories for several days following. Printed stories ran in the Los Angeles Times (including a front page story the day after the event and a longer, more detailed article in the Business Section, with suggestions on how to prevent damage to your home through structural and nonstructural mitigation efforts); the San Diego Union Tribune; Associated Press State and Local Wire; and the New York Times (including a website, www.nytimes.com/quakes, which also features the video footage captured by USC's Distance Education Network on behalf of the CUREe Woodframe Project Element 5). Scientific American, Popular Science, and the Chronicle of Higher Education conducted interviews with Project Managers, and articles are scheduled to appear in upcoming issues.

CUREe conducted a live webcast during the test; Websurfers should go to www.curee.org to view archived footage.

Photos before, during and after the test


Exterior shot seconds prior to earthquake simulation.
Photo Credit: Jason Chan, USC Distance Education Network

 


Flower pots fall and furniture topples as the test home is subjected
to near fault ground motions experienced in the 1994 6.7 Northridge
Earthquake.
Photo Credit: John Miller, UCSD Media Services



UCSD Structural engineers evaluate minor damage to the test home.
A preliminary conclusion is that the stucco finish helps add to the
structural integrity of the house.
Photo credit: Frieder Seible, UCSD Structural Engineering

 


The home was furnished with three water heaters. During the quake,
the unsecured water heater toppled, while the two heaters which were
properly tied down remained standing.
Photo Credit: Ricardo Guthrie, UCSD Communications

 

 

For more information on the Woodframe Project, Testing procedures and results, CEA and OES support, please contact:

John F. Hall
CUREe-Caltech Woodframe Project Manager
Professor, California Institute of Technology
626/395-4160
johnhall@its.caltech.edu

Robert Reitherman
CUREe-Caltech Woodframe Project Director
Executive Director, CUREe
510/231-9557
reitherman@curee.org

André Filiatrault
CUREe-Caltech Woodframe Project Principal Investigator, Testing & Analysis
Professor, UCSD Jacobs School of Engineering
858/822-2161
afiliatr@soemailucsd.edu

Frieder Seible
CUREe-Caltech Woodframe Project Manager, Testing and Analysis
Professor, UCSD Jacobs School of Engineering
858/534-4640
seible@ucsd.edu

Chia-Ming Uang
CUREe-Caltech Woodframe Project Assistant Manager, Testing and Analysis
Professor, UCSD Jacobs School of Engineering
858/534-9880
cmu@ucsd.edu

Mark Leonard
California Earthquake Authority
Sacramento, California
916/492-4319
leonardm@calquake.com

Greg Renick
Public Information Officer
Governor's Office of Emergency Services
562/795-2941
gregory_renick@oes.ca.gov

 



Phone 213/740-5843
Fax 213/740-0011
e-mail: SCECinfo@usc.edu